The Canary Murder Case

Here, in a few commonplace words, is the bleak, unadorned statement of one of the most astonishing crimes in the police annals of this countryÑa crime so contradictory, so baffling, so ingenious, so unique, that for many days the best minds of the Police Department and the District AttorneyÕs office were completely at a loss as to even a method of approach. Each line of investigation only tended to prove that Margaret Odell could not possibly have been murdered. And yet, huddled on the great silken davenport in her living-room lay the girlÕs strangled body, giving the lie to so grotesque a conclusion.

The true story of this crime, as it eventually came to light after a disheartening period of utter darkness and confusion, revealed many strange and bizarre ramifications, many dark recesses of manÕs unexplored nature, and the uncanny subtlety of a human mind sharpened by desperate and tragic despair. And it also revealed a hidden page of passional melodrama which, in its essence and organisms, was no less romantic and fascinating than that vivid, theatrical section of the ComŽdie Humaine which deals with the fabulous love of Baron Nucingen for Esther van Gobseck, and with the unhappy TorpilleÕs tragic death.

Margaret Odell was a product of the bohemian demi-monde of BroadwayÑa scintillant figure who seemed somehow to typify the gaudy and spurious romance of transient gaiety. For nearly two years before her death she had been the most conspicuous and, in a sense, popular figure of the cityÕs night life. In our grandparentsÕ day she might have had conferred upon her that somewhat questionable designation, Òthe toast of the townÓ; but to-day there are too many aspirants for this classification, too many cliques and violent schisms in the Lepidoptera of our cafŽ life, to permit of any one competitor being thus singled out. But, for all the darlings of both professional and lay press-agents, Margaret Odell was a character of unquestioned fame in her little world.

Her notoriety was due in part to certain legendary tales of her affairs with one or two obscure potentates in the backwashes of Europe. She had spent two years abroad after her first success in ÒThe Bretonne MaidÓÑa popular musical comedy in which she had been mysteriously raised from obscurity to the rank of ÒstarÓÑand, one may cynically imagine, her press-agent took full advantage of her absence to circulate vermilion tales of her conquests.

Her appearance went far toward sustaining her somewhat equivocal fame. There was no question that she was beautiful in a hard, slightly flamboyant way. I remember seeing her dancing one night at the Antlers ClubÑa famous rendezvous for post-midnight pleasure-seekers, run by the notorious Red Raegan. She impressed me then as a girl of uncommon loveliness, despite the calculating, predatory cast of her features. She was of medium height, slender, graceful in a leonine way, and, I thought, a trifle aloof and even haughty in mannerÑa result, perhaps, of her reputed association with European royalty. She had the traditional courtesanÕs full, red lips, and the wide, mongoose eyes of RossettiÕs ÒBlessed Damozel.Ó There was in her face that strange combination of sensual promise and spiritual renunciation with which the painters of all ages have sought to endow their conceptions of the Eternal Magdalene. Hers was the type of face, voluptuous and with a hint of mystery, which rules manÕs emotions and, by subjugating his mind, drives him to desperate deeds.